I’ve just finished watching the Syfy (ugh, still hate typing that stupid re-brand) remake of Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, and I’m coming away from it feeling pleased but slightly dizzy.

This remake was more in the style of Alice in Wonderland rather than just a retelling of the original story, which I think, for the most part, was a wise decision. The original story is disorienting and odd, and it seems as though the primary force behind Alice was to overlay those surrealist, wackadoo aesthetics onto an actual plotline that made some logical sense. For example – in this version, Alice is lured into Wonderland by a hunky dude with chiseled cheekbones (as opposed to chasing a stressed-out rabbit with an oversized pocket watch). We also discover pretty quickly that Wonderland has some specific and well-organized evil going on, a system where people from the real world are harvested for their emotions, and the Queen of Hearts feeds those feelings back to citizens of Wonderland to keep them subdued. It’s a cool if not completely original idea, and it works well for Wonderland. On top of that, the whole look of the place is entertaining. The palace/casino is full of surreally re-imagined sixties outfits with a heavily represented deck of cards theme, and the rest of Wonderland veers from steampunk-urban to forest of Endor and back again.

Unfortunately, what is supposed to be a reasonably logical and coherent plotline ends up being a little predictable and slow. In the beginning, Alice mourns her lost father, who abandoned her at a young age. Two hours later – surprise! – he’s in Wonderland! There’s also a whole bit with a skeleton army at the end that makes very little sense, and I’m still trying to figure out how it helped the conclusion. My other big complaint about this remake is that although most of the original, memorable characters show up, the newly coherent plotline has a hard time incorporating them, so they appear and disappear rather quickly, and are almost always drained of their initial creepiness. Caterpillar is mostly innocuous and Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum are less-than-terrifying torturers. The Cheshire Cat was also completely robbed, making a split second appearance that I found totally unsatisfying. I do have to agree with this piece from io9, though, that the Mad Hatter was the highlight of the whole miniseries. Not only was he adorable, he helped humanize Alice and made it easier to feel connected to the drifting, occasionally unmoored Wonderland plot.
It was a smart move to make Alice a significant departure from its original, particularly given the imminent arrival of the much higher-profile Tim Burton film remake. It was generally enjoyable, but if the whole thing had been tighter and more carefully plotted, it could have been memorable as well as merely entertaining.












